Strategy Inc. (NASDAQ:MSTR) is facing renewed scrutiny as the company faces an unprecedented $10 billion unrealized loss on its Bitcoin (CRYPTO: BTC) holdings.

What Is Going Wrong For Michael Saylor

Market commentator Kyle argued on X on June 4 that the company's preferred-share dividend obligations could turn Michael Saylor from Bitcoin's biggest buyer into a potential forced seller.

The company’s Bitcoin accumulation model worked while the company funded purchases through equity issuance, convertible notes and other financing tools that did not require near-term cash payments.

The concern now is that Strategy's newer preferred-share products, including (NASDAQ:STRC) and (NASDAQ:STRD), carry yield obligations.

Strategy owns roughly 4% of Bitcoin's total supply, making its balance sheet one of the biggest swing factors in crypto markets.

Kyle argued that earlier Strategy financing was easier for bulls to defend because common equity had no guaranteed return. The company could sell stock, buy Bitcoin and rely on BTC's long-term appreciation to support the share price.

Preferred shares change the math, he said.

Strategy's dividend obligations create a cash-flow issue because Bitcoin does not generate income. Strategy's core software business is small relative to the company's Bitcoin holdings.

The Three Paths Strategy Can Take

Kyle laid out three possible options for Strategy:

  • Pause dividend payments: This could preserve cash, but he said it may damage confidence in Strategy-linked preferred products.
  • Raise more capital: Strategy could sell more equity or issue more debt, but that may keep the cycle dependent on continued investor demand.
  • Sell Bitcoin: Kyle called this the worst-case scenario because it could pressure BTC and shake confidence in the broader bull market.

The ‘Egg Man' Risk

Kyle said Strategy's size creates a market overhang because buyers may hesitate if they believe a major seller could arrive.

He ended with a Wall Street joke about a trader who corners the egg market, then asks his broker to sell. The broker replies: "To who? You're the egg man."

In that sense Strategy helped extend Bitcoin rallies when Saylor was buying.

If the market starts pricing Strategy as a future seller instead, that same force could work in reverse.

Image: Shutterstock