Jersey Mike’s Subs (NYSE:JMKE) began its journeyas a public company on July 31, setting its IPO (initial public offering) price at $23 per share.
- RBC Capital Markets analyst Logan Reich initiated coverage with an Outperform rating and price target of $28.
- Guggenheim Securities analyst Gregory Francfort started coverage with a Buy rating and price target of $28.
- TD Cowen analyst Andrew Charles began coverage with a Buy rating and price target of $26.
- BTIG analyst Peter Saleh initiated coverage with a Buy rating and price target of $28.
Check out other analyst stock ratings.
RBC Capital Markets: Jersey Mike’s is gaining market share in the U.S. sandwich category, which is estimated at around $40 billion. Reich praised the brand’s “unique national marketing campaigns,” which separate it from sandwich peers.”
System sales have grown 26.2% since 2023, versus flat growth in the US sandwich category, he added.
Reich expects the company to continue gaining market share, driven by:
- Competitor closures
- Growing advertising fund
- Best-in-class ROIC (return on invested capital) on new units
Jersey Mike’s same-store sales growth has been positive for more than 20 years, "an accomplishment no other public restaurant brand (and only a couple of privates) has achieved," Reich wrote. The company currently has a presence in the US and Canada, and is expected to launch in the UK this year.
Guggenheim Securities: The top 15 U.S. sandwich brands generated sales of around $32 billion in 2025, about flat versus 2024 despite a decline of around 1% in store count, Francfort said. This softness led by market share leader Subway and headwinds at Panera Bread "have left room for Jersey Mike’s to take substantial market share," he added.
The company has the potential to grow from 3,300 U.S. units to more than 7,500 units, with additional runway in the international markets. The stock is trading at a "compelling" valuation, given Jersey Mike’s strong growth outlook and an opportunity to gain substantial share "in a category that has a $9bn market leader shedding traffic," he further wrote.
TD Cowen: Jersey Mike’s has a track record of 20 consecutive years of positive same-store sales and could generate 2.4%, 2.5% and 2.5% growth in 2026, 2027 and 2028, respectively, Charles said. The company is likely to be successful in prioritizing digital and personalization efforts, given the track record of CEO Charlie Morrison and team that was previously at Wingstop Inc (NASDAQ:WING), he added.
The Tinton Falls, New Jersey-based company expects to achieve net restaurant growth of 8.3%, 8.8% and 8.9% in 2026, 2027 and 2028, respectively. Charles also praised the company for being "on its way to ultimately surpass Subway and become the sandwich category leader.”
BTIG: Jersey Mike’s has nearly doubled its market share over the past five years, claiming the number two industry position, "driven by high-single-digit unit growth and consistent same-store sales gains," Saleh said. He added that the Buy rating reflects the company’s:
- Strong brand awareness
- Market share trajectory
- Long-term potential
- Solid financial model
Jersey Mike’s has posted among the strongest growth in the industry over the past two decades, the analyst noted. "We see a path to Jersey Mike’s eventually claiming the number one category position sometime early next decade, through continued system sales growth and competitive weakness," he further wrote.
JMKE Price Action: Shares of Jersey Mike’s had declined by 1.22% to $23.57 at the time of publication on Monday.
Image: Shutterstock
Login to comment